I enjoyed this a lot. Putting battleships into AoK? Gold. This was done is a very proffessional manner. There were no bugs. Not a lot to say since everyone knows what battleship is, but I'll explain anyways. You start out with a horse which you move onto a grid. You move another horse to confirm that move then a ship apears on a different grid. You get to place 12 ships. Once the 12 are placed you use the same method to "shoot" at the other player.
Both players start with the same everything so it's exactly balanced.
Well you did take it from one of the oldest board games ever, but the finece and perfection you put into it kept the rating above a 3.
Map Design: 4
Map design was good for utilitrian purposes, but wasn't to attractive. Could you have put deep water and shallow water for the ship grid? the swamp shallows didn't look good. Other than that it was pretty good.
Explained it to a T. There were diplayed instructions in English and German.
Additional Comments: Pretty fun if you enjoyed battleships the first time around. I recommend it, if not to play it, then just to look at the trigger work. (Damn!)