Playability: I didn;t think this map was very fun, mainly because of the lack of instructions for the player! I NEVER got any instructions on what to do. The map would be a bit better with instructions.
Balance: The blue player's army is way too big to defeat. I mean, come on, they had about 200 more men than I did! I would BALANCE this out a bit, maybe make some bandits attack the enemy castle, with triggers.
Creativity: I think this was pretty creative, but it kind of copies the Noryang Point campaign in TC. If you have TC I blame you, if you dont, then oh well! I like the way the Persians attack the Koreans. Definitely unrealistic, but still fun.
Map Design: Pretty well done, for a random map script. ;)
I liked the way you designed the castles though. That was nice how the trebuchets were positioned between the walls of the turkish (Persian) castle.
Story/Instructions: No instructions apeared, so I gave this a 3. The messages tab was pretty blank, so I suggest filling this in!
Overall- Fun map, but unbalanced. Good town design.
To the author:Just add some more triggers, a full message tab, and you'll be pretty good to go!