I think this was quite good beeing my first single player file so please dont moan if it is not that good. in this scenario you command an army of Chu-ko-nus and you set out to destroy some non ranged units camp because they destroy all your long bow men in a volcano.
'when chu-ko-nus attack!' is a FF, you command an army of Chu Ko Nu.
PLAYABILITY: You walk a pathetic map with an army of 253 Chu Ko Nu to slaughter an inferior enemy; the scenario has no game play. 1
BALANCE: The scenario is too easy on hard, even though the enemy has about twenty units more he is no match without range units. 1
CREATIVITY: There was a spark of creativity in the opening scene but failed as the three related chat messages do not display. 1+
MAP DESIGN: The map is flat, editor green with square palisade walls, a castle, a tent and clumped blacksmiths and barracks. 1
STORY/INSTRUCTIONS: The introduction screen is blank, no objective and no story. 1
SUGGESTIONS: For your messages use source player 1 instead of source Gaia. Play some higher rated scenarios, make your scenario challenging so the player can loose, try a story, give an objective, use a random map and put more time and effort into your design.
OBSERVATION: I am aware that this scenario will get an above average number of downloads simply because people are interested in what qualifies for an overall one. I tried to avoid an overall one, finding a category that qualifies for a higher rating, but a reviewer has to be consistent with his rating and rate every category on its own.
IN CLOSING: The above is not a recommendation to download.