Map : Snow on Arabia? lol great! this is a nice theme, however, not really historical, and I can't really think about a good story for this... That's why a 3... If you made something in snow with some historical background, I'd like to give a 4
You made the idea of snow and Arabia map work
And you made it possible to add enough new stuff without losing the Theme...
Good job! However Not one of the best ^^
Visual Appeal: 3
Not good, not bad
You used 1 type of forest... Snow pine forests... okey, it's a snowy land... But what if you also use some places with some grass and normal pine forests on them? Also, you used snow, snow grass, and snow dirt... snow road maybe? or grass -> normal pine on them
Also, I didn't see any height level difference... All level 2... Maybe you could make some hills or 'craters'?
Still, nice job
Too less gold... I had to sell a lot of wood to get more gold
Eye candy :
You could've used more... If you use some grass spots, like I said before, you could add some stuff like flower beds or something
Using the Elevation levels could be useful/beautiful also here...
Matches Eachother... All snowy... But I'd like to see some grass also... Even if it are just some small spots...
Place for buildings :
Way to much... You can fix all these empty places with some more resources/forest, small water spots, just like the real Arabia map...
However, If you like to build a lot of buildings, this map is perfect...
Okay, It's not that kinda great...
First of all, I didn't had that much fun... Some reasons you can read above... Less Elevation (extually, none...), no water, you could use some small water spots like Arabia, I had too much space for my walls... I always like to put them between forests, or cliffs or water or something...
Maybe you can work this out just a bit?