There were many bugs in the game and there was (almost) no trigger/AI for the enemy.
Very easy. There totally was no challenge playing the game. The map of Moria I played in 5 seconds.
The author was not being creative at all. It was also a bad idea to make the hobbits villagers. And at the 2nd scenario and at the Moria scenario I didn't even know what actually happened.
Map Design: 2
The author did almost nothing designing the map. What more to say?
Poor. You could at least explain what to do in the scenario.