You mean Philip Dunscombe? I believe you were the one who found out many of the tricks we use now?
I wonder how many such threads there are, btw.
To be true there are many different types of scenarios, you can't just lump all of them into one and ask 'which is the best' I suggest you put them into separate categories such as
(these are the best ones according to me, not exclusive)
Best campaign (more than 1 scenario)
-The King's Best Men by Ingo
-Ulio, by Ingo
-Bouren, by Tonto Dave
...
Best scenario (mix)
-Sabato Returns, by BJ
-Vlad Dracula, by Great Emperor
-Wolfcastle2 silence of the clowns, by Andres_age
-When the Wheel Breaks, by Ingo
-The Way of the Warrior, by Great Emperor
-Cupid's Poisoned Arrows by Boosh
etc.
Best FF
-Tannenberg, by McCrnigoj
-Hattin 1187, by McCrnigoj
-Crusade, the beginning, by Sceletar
-The siege of Prethonia, by Mashek
-Cave of Doom, by Oliver
-War of Troy, by Sceletar
Best cutscene
-Immortal prey, by Crasher
-Legends of Chila, by Oliver
Best B&D
...
Best mini-scenario
...
and so on. I propose we should have some poll of this sort shortly?