I am Stan in the blacksmith, and I am probably one of the strictest reviewers out there.
Here's how I rate:
Playability:
1 - Really bad and laggy or have more than 1 bugs
2 - Bad and laggy, if I want to quit within 6 minutes it will get this score
3 - Average, the most common score I give
4 - Above average, second most common score I give
5 - Exceptional. Only gave it out twice
Balance:
1 - Extremely easy or unchallenging
2 - Bad, too easy
3 - Average, most common scorw
4 - Pretty good, but not perfect
5 - Prefection
Creativity:
1 - A random map type of thing
2 - A map similar to a random map
3 - Basic stuff that are used in specialty maps
4 - Used something uncommon or hard to execute
5 - Use of several uncommon or hard to execute things
Map Design: Same a Spineman's, unfortunately .Story/Instructions:
1 - No insturctions nor any story
2 - Has a story but no instructions
3 - Has instructions but no story
4 - Have a story and instructions, but the story is only soso
5 - Have an excellent story with instructions
http://www.scnnetwork.com/corners/stan
Nobody forced you to read that site, remember
[This message has been edited by The Conquistador (edited 11-29-2000).]