I´ve come up with a (IMO) great idea. What about a “Campaign Contest”? During a certain amount of time everyone that feel for it could upload a campaign, and announce (in this thread) that their campaign is a part of the contest. Then the reviewers (not just anyone, only the experienced reviewers would be allowed to act as judges) would review these campaigns just like a normal campaign. Then the five best campaigns would be in a final. In the final, the judges crown a winner. What do you think?
Here follows an update of the rules.
Now I have read your posts andI have taken them into account. and now i sit here to write some detailed rules and a list of contestants/reviewers.After some rules i have a motivation marked with a "M:". Sometimes there is a question ("Q:") and an answer ("A:")
Rules:
Time:
- The Contest will start on 030920, 00:00 (greenwich time).
Q: What does that mean?
A: It means that the rules can not be changed after that.
- The campaigns has to be released between 031030 and 040130. (At "The Blacksmith").
Q: Do have have to post it before 040130 or does o have to be uploaded before that time.
A: It has to be uploaded, so send it in a bit earlier.
The Campaigns
- Any type of campaign is allowed.
- It doesn´t matter how many scenarios you have.
- You can use custom AI:s as you want to.
- A creator must only send in one campaign.
- Each campaign has to be done by only one person (AIs not counted).
- Any creator is free to join in until 040130
Reviewing
- The reviewing will be done by experienced reviewers with at least 5 reviews posted at the blacksmith (040130).
- A reviewer is not allowed to compete in the contest.
- A reviewer is not allowed to playtest a campaign. (Any camp. paytested by a reviewer will be disqualified).
-The official judges has to play all the campaigns i the final.
How will we get a winner?
First, all campaigns will be reviewed at least once.Anyone can do these reviews (except contestants). The 5 best campaigns will go to the final ( in case two camps. got the same score, both will go to final. This apply also to threee campaigns having the same score. (this means that there can be 7 camps in the final, however there can not be 8 camps in the final. In case 4 camps draw the 5th position, only one of these camps (chosen by the official judes together) will go to the final.
In the final, teh official judges will have a big discussion about which camp. being the best.
List of contestants/official judges:
Judges:
Mechstra
Jr_Capablanca
Clayperboy
Lord Fadawah
Contestants (and score):
The X king - 4.2
Innuedo Alert - 5.0
Crasher - 4.8
Reich - 3.8
AnastasiaKafka - 4.867
Serve 240 - 3.4
rayoflightsword - 3.533
Puzzleman - 4.2
MCrnigoj - 4.9
Great Emperor - 4.9
Tlaloc - 3.8
/Capa
[This message has been edited by Angel Aro (edited 08-16-2004 @ 01:44 PM).]