You must be logged in to post messages.
Please login or register

Scenario Design and Discussion
Moderated by Sebastien, Mr Wednesday

Hop to:    
Welcome! You are not logged in. Please Login or Register.66 replies
Age of Kings Heaven » Forums » Scenario Design and Discussion » Review guideline changes: VOTING THREAD
Bottom
Topic Subject:Review guideline changes: VOTING THREAD
« Previous Page  1 2  Next Page »
Mr Wednesday
Cavalier
(id: matty12345)
posted 07-10-08 08:13 AM CT (US)         
To make it painstakingly obvious so that nobody can complain they did not get a chance to voice their opinion, we will have the voting take place in this thread. Vote for which changes you would like to see as we go through the main issues.

THe first thing which is currently being decided is whether we as a community prefer an overall score to be given by the scenarios, or an averaged score of the 5 categories. This does not have anything to do with the various changes we have discussed, merely vote which system you prefer.

If you are unclear or wish to debate, please do so in this thread HERE. Try to keep this thread to mainly votes so when we count it is easier.

Post one of the following options:

Vote: Averaged Categories

or

Vote: Overall Score

If you already voted in the other thread, do not repost I am collecting those votes and will add them to the tally in this thread.



Averaged Categories
--------------------
Julius999
Lord Basse
Mashek (White Dragon)
Jon Mendl


Overall Score
--------------------
Andrew Dunn
Jatayu
Turty

[This message has been edited by matty12345 (edited 07-10-2008 @ 08:17 AM).]

AuthorReplies:
UnnamedPlayer
Squire
posted 07-10-08 01:06 PM CT (US)     1 / 66       
Me: Overall Score
Takk
Squire
(id: Luke_Feanor)
posted 07-10-08 06:13 PM CT (US)     2 / 66       
I don't think it's the best way but miles better than the alternative.

Vote: Averaged categories.

Lucas is boss.
Andanu Trisatya
Squire
posted 07-11-08 02:38 AM CT (US)     3 / 66       
Vote: Averaged Categories

...along with revamped guidelines, if I might add.

████████
████████
/\NDANU TRISATY/\
The Least Skilled Member of StormWind Studios

-:|:- Blacksmith Files -:|:- Fabula Fatali -:|:- Photography -:|:- Age of Kings Heaven -:|:-
viperiv
Squire
(id: EpIc CoMmandeR)
posted 07-11-08 02:39 AM CT (US)     4 / 66       
Vote: Overall Score
Kor
Busschof Happertesch
(id: Derfel Cadarn)
posted 07-11-08 07:46 AM CT (US)     5 / 66       
Vote: Overall Score

Kor | The Age of Chivalry is upon us!
Wellent ich gugk, so hindert mich / köstlicher ziere sinder,
Der ich e pflag, da für ich sich / Neur kelber, gaiss, böck, rinder,
Und knospot leut, swarz, hässeleich, / Vast rüssig gen dem winder;
Die geben müt als sackwein vich. / Vor angst slach ich mein kinder
Offt hin hinder.
Luke Gevaerts
Squire
posted 07-11-08 08:48 AM CT (US)     6 / 66       
I'd vote for insta-gibbing every reviewer that has forsaken his or her common sense to the internet... Alas. My vote is for Overall Score.

Luke Gevaerts » Website · YouTube · Backloggery

"Some scientists claim that hydrogen, because it is so plentiful, is the basic building block of the universe. I dispute that.
I say there is more stupidity than hydrogen, and that is the basic building block of the universe." - Frank Zappa

OD · AoKH
Dead_End
Cavalier
posted 07-11-08 09:16 AM CT (US)     7 / 66       
Vote: Averaged Categories
KayanZ
Squire
(id: ZayanK)
posted 07-11-08 12:08 PM CT (US)     8 / 66       
Overall Score.

gogogo
crasher
Squire
posted 07-11-08 03:09 PM CT (US)     9 / 66       
I'd vote for insta-gibbing every reviewer that has forsaken his or her common sense to the internet... Alas. My vote is for Overall Score.
insta-gibbing? The heck?

I think I'd lean in the direction of an overall score from what I've gathered in the discussion so far, but don't count that as a vote.

I think moving to a 10.0 point reviewing system, (or allowing people to give 5.0 points in increments of 0.5) is what I'd like to see more...

Matt - "Crasher"
Gwame
Squire
posted 07-11-08 03:58 PM CT (US)     10 / 66       
Vote: Overall Score

MY NAME IS GWAME I AM AOKH MEMBER SINCE 2004 AND I HAVE MANY POSTS
BEST SIG OF 2008 AND 2ND BEST SIG OF 2009 (SAME SIG LOLOL)
BEST SIG OF 2008
92% of teenagers have moved on to rap music. If you're on of the 8% that still listens to real music, copy this into your signature.
"^`'*-=~+,._.,+~=-*'`^" "Gwame your sig ain't funny nomore." - morgoth bauglir"^`'*-=~+,._.,+~=-*'`^"
morgoth bauglir
Squire
posted 07-11-08 04:28 PM CT (US)     11 / 66       
Vote: Overall score
insta-gibbing? The heck?
UT, yes? Makes people explode into pieces and pieces of them flying. Made UT what it is today.

Morgoth Bauglir/Quaazi - BORINGMETAL HEADTWAT
Huidin's Belief - The Siege (4.4) - 2475 - Birth Of The Uruk-Hai (4.1) (Best Sound of 2008)
Signature currently under construction. If you want to help out and provide me with the resources needed, download from the above links.
hunnic paladin
Squire
posted 07-11-08 06:20 PM CT (US)     12 / 66       
VOTE: Averaged Categories

H U N N I C ~ P A L A D I N
HP is a very nice guy who'd rather be polite and nod his head in agreement to other people's opinions, than act tough and bluntly. -Andanu Trisatya
On another note, I read that you are 13, I must say that I think that you are very knowledgeable for 13. -street (That was a long time ago...)
Mystery Maze III - Currently Stalled - 39.8% Complete
Gwame
Squire
posted 07-11-08 06:22 PM CT (US)     13 / 66       
Update the topic post

MY NAME IS GWAME I AM AOKH MEMBER SINCE 2004 AND I HAVE MANY POSTS
BEST SIG OF 2008 AND 2ND BEST SIG OF 2009 (SAME SIG LOLOL)
BEST SIG OF 2008
92% of teenagers have moved on to rap music. If you're on of the 8% that still listens to real music, copy this into your signature.
"^`'*-=~+,._.,+~=-*'`^" "Gwame your sig ain't funny nomore." - morgoth bauglir"^`'*-=~+,._.,+~=-*'`^"
Carlos Ferdinand
Squire
posted 07-12-08 02:45 AM CT (US)     14 / 66       
Vote : Averaged Categories

Reason : Otherwise IMO, people will start giving more biased ratings and may not justify why this game has a better score etc. By averaged categories, people must give scores of all categories and in this way, it can give a better way of scoring.

CARLOS FERDINAND 2-- THE MEDITERRANEAN DRIZZLE

MY GOTH MEN-AT-ARMS STRATEGY
CARLOS FERDINAND - 1. A KINGDOM'S DAWN

"I may disagree with what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it" - Voltaire
Fattybryce
Squire
posted 07-12-08 02:48 AM CT (US)     15 / 66       
average

The Wall

coming soon
four hundred babies
Squire
(id: Lord_Fadawah)
posted 07-12-08 03:34 AM CT (US)     16 / 66       
Powery
Squire
posted 07-12-08 10:57 AM CT (US)     17 / 66       
Categories
Luke Gevaerts
Squire
posted 07-12-08 01:31 PM CT (US)     18 / 66       
It's funny to see how every old-timer here is voting for Overal Score.

Three guesses as to what we'll likely not be getting.

Luke Gevaerts » Website · YouTube · Backloggery

"Some scientists claim that hydrogen, because it is so plentiful, is the basic building block of the universe. I dispute that.
I say there is more stupidity than hydrogen, and that is the basic building block of the universe." - Frank Zappa

OD · AoKH
Mechstra
Banned
posted 07-12-08 01:44 PM CT (US)     19 / 66       
Yes, this will be a landslide win for the categories, it seems.

Then there'll be a move towards a .5 scale in each category because that allows for more accuracy.
Stephen Richards
Squire
posted 07-12-08 03:04 PM CT (US)     20 / 66       
Overall Score
Kor
Busschof Happertesch
(id: Derfel Cadarn)
posted 07-12-08 03:25 PM CT (US)     21 / 66       
A landslide win for categories? Not really.
Present count:

Averaged Categories: 14
--------------------
Lord Basse
Mashek (White Dragon)
Jon Mendl
Mascherano
Andanu Trisatya
Dead_End
Hunnic Paladin
Carlos Ferdinand
Fattybryce
Powery
ViperIV
Crazedmaniac
Tanneur99
cat

Overall Score: 15+1
--------------------
Andrew Dunn
Jatayu
Turty
UnnamedPlayer
Kor
Luke Gevaerts
ZayanK
Gwame
Quaazi
Lord_Fadawah
Stephen Richards
Pulkit
thepunkguy
sly_guy
Clibinarii

(crasher)

Abstain: 2
--------------------
Julius999
AnastasiaKafka

Kor | The Age of Chivalry is upon us!
Wellent ich gugk, so hindert mich / köstlicher ziere sinder,
Der ich e pflag, da für ich sich / Neur kelber, gaiss, böck, rinder,
Und knospot leut, swarz, hässeleich, / Vast rüssig gen dem winder;
Die geben müt als sackwein vich. / Vor angst slach ich mein kinder
Offt hin hinder.

[This message has been edited by Kor (edited 07-22-2008 @ 06:15 AM).]

Luke Gevaerts
Squire
posted 07-12-08 04:13 PM CT (US)     22 / 66       
Then there'll be a move towards a .5 scale in each category because that allows for more accuracy.
Just be happy you're still allowed to write a review.

Luke Gevaerts » Website · YouTube · Backloggery

"Some scientists claim that hydrogen, because it is so plentiful, is the basic building block of the universe. I dispute that.
I say there is more stupidity than hydrogen, and that is the basic building block of the universe." - Frank Zappa

OD · AoKH
crasher
Squire
posted 07-12-08 08:01 PM CT (US)     23 / 66       
LOL, Luke.

I'll just be pissed if IP gets anything less than a 5.00000!

And wow, thanks for sorta counting my vote! I guess I'd say that if it comes down to a tie-breaker, I'd say count my vote, but I sorta thought it would be a landslide too.

I guess "alone we stand, together we fall apart" hehe... (the strokes)


Matt - "Crasher"
AnastasiaKafka
Squire
posted 07-12-08 09:35 PM CT (US)     24 / 66       
This is like shopping for shoes. Can I have both?

"I take it that this is the Anastasia Scud pines for?" - Epic Commander
"What Ana said. Use sugar and the whip." - aka the Pilot
"I think you will realize the emphasis was on Ana and Cake." - Monk
four hundred babies
Squire
(id: Lord_Fadawah)
posted 07-13-08 01:11 AM CT (US)     25 / 66       
Of course, we all understand that this poll doesn't mean anything.
Pulkit
Squire
posted 07-13-08 02:19 AM CT (US)     26 / 66       
Nonetheless, vote: Overall Score.

Tales of Middle-Earth | Don't miss it
morgoth bauglir
Squire
posted 07-13-08 03:07 AM CT (US)     27 / 66       
Yay Ana!

Morgoth Bauglir/Quaazi - BORINGMETAL HEADTWAT
Huidin's Belief - The Siege (4.4) - 2475 - Birth Of The Uruk-Hai (4.1) (Best Sound of 2008)
Signature currently under construction. If you want to help out and provide me with the resources needed, download from the above links.
Andanu Trisatya
Squire
posted 07-13-08 05:34 PM CT (US)     28 / 66       
Whichever option gets to be applied, know that it would be the best for the sake of this community, so no hard feelings.

████████
████████
/\NDANU TRISATY/\
The Least Skilled Member of StormWind Studios

-:|:- Blacksmith Files -:|:- Fabula Fatali -:|:- Photography -:|:- Age of Kings Heaven -:|:-
Luke Gevaerts
Squire
posted 07-13-08 07:57 PM CT (US)     29 / 66       
Whichever option gets to be applied, know that it would be the best for the sake of this community, so no hard feelings.
Bullshit. It's not about the community. It's never been about the community. Not for some, at any rate.

Luke Gevaerts » Website · YouTube · Backloggery

"Some scientists claim that hydrogen, because it is so plentiful, is the basic building block of the universe. I dispute that.
I say there is more stupidity than hydrogen, and that is the basic building block of the universe." - Frank Zappa

OD · AoKH
Takk
Squire
(id: Luke_Feanor)
posted 07-13-08 08:18 PM CT (US)     30 / 66       
Sigh.

Give it a rest. Sometimes people won't agree with you Luke and when they do they haven't got some deep dark personal motive behind it.

Lucas is boss.
Luke Gevaerts
Squire
posted 07-14-08 06:06 AM CT (US)     31 / 66       
Sometimes people won't agree with you Luke [...]
Those who do not agree with me tend to be either new, or staff members. I'm surprised you don't see a pattern here.
[...] and when they do they haven't got some deep dark personal motive behind it.
I haven't got a deep, dark, personal motive. On the contrary: my motives are perfectly clear. I want a new set of reviewing guidelines; and I'd like for some HG staff members to finally admit that they're more conservative than the Tories.

Luke Gevaerts » Website · YouTube · Backloggery

"Some scientists claim that hydrogen, because it is so plentiful, is the basic building block of the universe. I dispute that.
I say there is more stupidity than hydrogen, and that is the basic building block of the universe." - Frank Zappa

OD · AoKH
Takk
Squire
(id: Luke_Feanor)
posted 07-14-08 06:41 AM CT (US)     32 / 66       
Those who do not agree with me tend to be either new, or staff members. I'm surprised you don't see a pattern here.
Er, not a good statement to make?
I haven't got a deep, dark, personal motive. On the contrary: my motives are perfectly clear. I want a new set of reviewing guidelines; and I'd like for some HG staff members to finally admit that they're more conservative than the Tories.
Oooh snap. I want a new set of reviewing guidelines too.

Conservative? Give it a break ffs. I'll direct you to Dave_Earl's post in the other thread and my response to it. Cheers, gg.

Lucas is boss.

[This message has been edited by Mascherano (edited 07-14-2008 @ 06:45 AM).]

cat
Squire
posted 07-14-08 06:41 AM CT (US)     33 / 66       
I vote: Overall Score
Julius999
Imposter
posted 07-14-08 10:12 AM CT (US)     34 / 66       
Please change my vote to an abstention. I don't want to derail our chance of getting any change at all.

1010011010
[ All_That_Glitters | Pretty_Town_Contest | Other_AoK_Designs | AoE_Designs ]
Member of Stormwind Studios
Kor
Busschof Happertesch
(id: Derfel Cadarn)
posted 07-14-08 10:43 AM CT (US)     35 / 66       
Okay. I'm keeping the tally in post 21 up to date, by the way, so that reflects the actual vote count. Ana, would you want me to put you in the abstain group?

Kor | The Age of Chivalry is upon us!
Wellent ich gugk, so hindert mich / köstlicher ziere sinder,
Der ich e pflag, da für ich sich / Neur kelber, gaiss, böck, rinder,
Und knospot leut, swarz, hässeleich, / Vast rüssig gen dem winder;
Die geben müt als sackwein vich. / Vor angst slach ich mein kinder
Offt hin hinder.
« Previous Page  1 2  Next Page »
You must be logged in to post messages.
Please login or register

Hop to:    

Age of Kings Heaven | HeavenGames